Toronto Public Library Workers Union

Below is the text of the Union's letter sent today to the City Librarian with a copy to the Toronto Public Library Board

**********************

Re: Room Booking at Palmerston Library

We are in receipt of your October 12 and your October 15 emails to all staff concerning the upcoming room rental by Meghan Murphy for the presentation “Gender Identity: What does It Mean for Society, the Law and Women?”

It is our opinion that the stated purpose of this room booking, “to have an educational and open discussion on the concept of gender identity and its legislation ramifications on women in Canada” is disingenuous, to say the least. Meghan Murphy has made her negative views towards the trans community and other non-binary equity-seeking groups very public.

Your October 15, 2019 email asks that attention be turned away from the room booking issue and redirected to civil debate with the speaker’s ‘ideas.’ However, while Murphy may not have been officially charged with hate speech under Canadian law, her views do, in fact, target highly vulnerable and marginalized communities not only in our workplace, but among library users in Toronto and beyond.   

Recent TPL public consultations with equity-seeking groups on how to make the library more "welcoming," inclusive, and relevant ring hollow if the very people they seek to validate are ultimately alienated by the real decisions and actions that run counter to purported values of equity and respect. 

The work that staff have done to reach out to community members, and to build trust and partnerships, has now been compromised to some extent by this decision.  For many, the library might no longer represent a safe and inclusive space.

We do ask that the Toronto Public Library reconsider its decision to allow this room booking to proceed. 

Librarian Glasses

Members Login Here:

Twitter icon

Recent Tweets

7h
RT @the_grayt_life @1946Cupe Thank you to @Local4948 Toronto Public Library. Great message, as always. If it’s important enough to have a…
Nov 17
Staffless Libraries: A Bad Idea. Reason #23 (Access Unreliable) Doors to @torontolibrary's Staffless Libraries oft… https://t.co/Y6v1QxfNvW
Nov 16
RT @progresstoronto: Thousands of people used our tool to tell City Council to take Ford to the Supreme Court & they're doing it! Now it's…
Nov 15
RT @CUPEOntario: With only a few weeks notice, workers mobilized to protect our right to appoint our Representatives to the OMERS Sponsors…
Nov 15
RT @gotanthro: Got Anthropology stands with trans folks and will no longer be holding events at the Lillian H. Smith branch of the Toronto…
Nov 15
RT @CUPE391: Why do you think that libraries are such great places? We love that library workers provide community gathering places for soc…
Nov 14
RT @torontolabour: Our senior organizer @mohashim deputing on the #PovertyReduction strategy at Exec Committee today: https://t.co/XxzL1yg7
Nov 14
RT @CUPEOntario: CUPE Ontario Executive Board Member Brittany Nisbett demanding better treatment for injured workers at Doug Ford’s constit…
Nov 14
#LibraryWarriors outside #OMERS protesting backroom deals that could affect our pension! With labour @Local4948https://t.co/YNJV2IWMnl
Nov 14
RT @CAPALacbes: CAPAL's board has published a statement on the Toronto Public Library’s October 29, 2019 Meghan Murphy event: https://t.co/
Nov 14
RT @patersonmonday: hii it’s trans awareness week! reposting my comic about last months @torontolibrary protest in solidarity with trans wo…
Nov 14
RT @krisjoseph: Open letter from the York University Faculty Association's Librarians and Archivists to the Toronto Public Library #librari
Nov 12
RT @CUPEOntario: Some at OMERS are trying to rig the rules to weaken the voices of workers and get rid of benefits like guaranteed indexing…
Nov 11
RT @cartwrightTO: Today we remember courage + sacrifice. WW1 was supposed to be "the war to end all wars". Millions died on battlefields s…
Nov 09
Staffless Libraries: A Bad Idea. Reason #56 (Technical Difficulties @torontolibrary offers access and training to… https://t.co/dFVmaqwzGQ
Nov 08
Urgent: to all CUPE workers who are part of the #OMERS pension plan. Read this important notice from @cupeontariohttps://t.co/5JxHC8QGMN
Nov 02
Staffless Libraries: A Bad Idea. Reason #19 (Poor Security) Workers @torontolibrary consistently report not feelin… https://t.co/nSgyX7hClg
Oct 31
RT @acmjis: Huge thanks as well to the many organizations that co-hosted & endorsed, incl @Local4948 @CJusticeTO @SURJto @MaggiesToront
Oct 31
RT @LibrarianshipCA: Hundreds protest Toronto library event featuring controversial speaker https://t.co/yfajY5xgXD
Oct 31
RT @marchollin @Local4948 @TPLWU4948Pres @CUPEOntario @PrideToronto @4948Warriors Thanks for the buttons, friends!!!
Oct 30
RT @dhunnasim: Going strong with #TakeBackTPL @acmjis has been leading a beautiful read-in of trans, non-binary, and two-spirit writers. A…
Oct 30
RT @joe_cressy: With you in spirit. If a broken policy is allowing discrimination to flourish, the policy must be changed. Our libraries sh…
Oct 30
RT @BillyRayB: On the same day she won one of the country’s top prizes in poetry @GwenBenaway is helping lead one of the most significant…
Oct 30
Handing out buttons at Palmerston Library. Thank you to all #libraryworkers + allies who were able to attend to su… https://t.co/HtxLSjun0q
Oct 29
RT @CPoTGDK: Libraries should be for everyone! Come show your support at Palmerston Library 6pm today Oct 29 #TakeBackTPL #ProtectTransKids
Oct 29
RT @fondfaun: hey look, it’s @GwenBenaway getting things off to a brilliant, passionate start at the @PrideToronto pre-#TakeBackTPL rally!…
Oct 29
RT @CUPEOntario: October 28, MPPs are back at Queen’s Park. The #powerofmany is telling them to end cuts to #publicservices #education, wo…
Oct 29
RT @fondfaun: omg CUPE @Local4948, the Toronto Public Library Workers Union, just endorsed our #TakeBackTPL protest!!!!!!!!! solidarity f…
Oct 28
“Planned event reignites debate about libraries’ role as forum for free speech...” https://t.co/x60NVFmNQMhttps://t.co/ZTZ4xHzENC
Oct 25
RT @CUPE905: To conclude Ontario Public Library Week, we highlight one of our longest standing library warriors, Kathy Coates. Kathy explai…
Oct 25
Staffless Libraries: A Bad Idea. Reason #5 (Theft @torontolibrary is the biggest and busiest urban public library… https://t.co/6DGH72umjt
Oct 25
RT @PrideToronto: UPDATE: PRIDE TORONTO'S TRANS RALLY- TUESDAY, OCTOBER 29, 2019 BARBARA HALL PARK. The Trans Rally will start at Barbara H…
Oct 25
RT @kristynwongtam: Thank you @GordPerks for your support of this motion to review the booking policies for city-owned facilities, includin…
Oct 25
RT @GraphicMatt: Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam has a motion on next week’s Council agenda asking for a report on ways to strengthen the City’…
Oct 23
RT @CPoTGDK: Our statement on @torontolibrary renting space to someone who promotes discrimination against trans people @JohnTory @vbowles
Oct 22
At TPL Board meeting. Multiple deputations to packed room + overflow. Pride Toronto, the 519 + citizens express opp… https://t.co/iDHGCLqSqg
Oct 20
RT @CUPE391Pres#CanadianLibraryWorkersDay Our members and #librarywarriors across the country love what they do, today and every day. Vis…
Oct 19
RT @PrideToronto: Pride Toronto’s Board of Directors public statement on Toronto Public Library’s decision to allow Meghan Murphy’s event t…
Oct 18
RT @JILLSLASTWORD: "As a proud member of Toronto’s queer community, I stand in solidarity with LGBTQ folks, as well as with local writers a…
Oct 17
RT @kayee13: I've been thinking of all the wonderful librarians and staff at TPL since all this happened. My respect and S/O to them for th…
Oct 17
RT @waharnum: This @Local4948 letter on the transphobic room booking situation at Toronto Public Library is excellent, proud of my old unio…
Oct 17
Staffless Libraries: A Bad Idea. Reason 13 (Inappropriate Computer Use @torontolibrary provides free computer and… https://t.co/vVZtxdIa8B
Oct 17
RT @torontolabour: Library warriors with @FredHahnCUPE at #occupyford today - calling on #Conservatives to enact the law + save lives! http…
Oct 17
RT @fairwagesnow: And you can help! Call Doug Ford and ask him to sign Section 83(4) of the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act to prevent…
Oct 17
RT @fairwagesnow: Shamefully @fordnation had the workers and constituents occupying his office arrested and taken out the back door. But t…
Oct 16
RT @PFrache: Incredible support here in #EtobicokeNorth! Ontario wants @fordnation to enact the law! Sign section 83(4) Protect temp agency…